He was asking for an autograph. That's all he was doing. He's a fan. He wasn't being a wise guy.
He got punched two or three times. He was taken to New York University Hospital. At the hospital, he indicated it was both of them who hit him.
My client was not aggressive in seeking the autograph. Melvin went in to get an autograph and got a knuckle sandwich instead.
My client was not aggressive in seeking the autograph.